If you buy leads from Angi, HomeAdvisor or Thumbtack, you know the number on the invoice. Maybe it is $35 a lead, maybe $80. But that number tells you almost nothing about whether the channel makes you money. The number that matters is what each booked job costs you.
This guide shows you how to work that out in ten minutes, why shared leads usually cost more than they look, and how to start moving to leads that only you receive.
The price per lead is the wrong number
Shared lead platforms make money by selling the same homeowner request to more than one company. That is the model. It means every lead starts as a race: the first company to call back usually wins, and the others paid for nothing.
It also means the homeowner is shopping. They submitted one form and got three calls, so they compare prices. Even when you win, you often win at a lower ticket.
The question to ask: not “how much is a lead?” but “how much did I spend on this channel for every job that actually landed on my schedule?”
How to work out your real cost per booked job
You need three numbers from the last 60 to 90 days:
- Total spent on the channel (lead fees, subscriptions, credits).
- Number of leads received.
- Number of those leads that became booked jobs.
Then: cost per booked job = total spent ÷ booked jobs.
Here is an illustrative example. These are not industry averages; plug in your own numbers.
| Shared leads | Exclusive leads (Google) | |
|---|---|---|
| Leads per month | 40 | 30 |
| Cost per lead | $45 | $60 |
| Monthly spend | $1,800 | $1,800 |
| Close rate | 15% | 45% |
| Booked jobs | 6 | 13 |
| Cost per booked job | $300 | $138 |
Same budget. The exclusive leads cost more each, yet each booked job costs less than half as much, because far more of them close.
Why exclusive leads close better
- They chose you. The homeowner saw your Google profile, your reviews and your photos, then called. Trust is already there.
- No race. Nobody else got the same request, so a two-minute delay doesn't lose the job.
- Less price shopping. People who call one company from a Map Pack listing compare less than people who fill in a form to get three quotes.
- You own the relationship. The customer's next call, review and referral come to you, not to a platform.
Where exclusive leads come from
- Google Business Profile and the Map Pack. The three map results at the top of “garage door repair near me” get a large share of calls. Ranking there takes a few months and keeps paying.
- Google Local Services Ads. Pay per lead, shown above everything else, with a Google badge. Leads come only to you.
- Google Search ads. Pay per click, controlled by job type and area. Works fast when tracking and negative keywords are right.
- Your website and SEO. A page for each job and each key city keeps producing calls without a per-lead fee.
- Reviews and referrals. More fresh reviews raise your Map Pack ranking and your close rate at the same time.
When shared leads still make sense
Shared leads are not always a bad deal. They can help when:
- You are a new company with few reviews and need jobs this month.
- You are testing a new service area before investing in it.
- Your schedule has gaps in a slow season and you can respond fast.
The mistake is treating them as the plan instead of a stopgap.
A 30-day plan to reduce your dependence
- Calculate your cost per booked job for every channel you use, using the formula above.
- Fix your Google Business Profile: categories, services, photos and hours.
- Apply for Local Services Ads if you haven't. Approval takes time, so start now.
- Set up a missed-call text-back so the leads you already get don't slip away.
- Start asking every customer for a Google review with a direct link.
After 60 to 90 days, compare cost per booked job again. Cut the shared lead budget only when your own channels beat it.
Want your numbers worked out for you?
Our free visibility audit includes a cost-per-job comparison of your current lead sources.
Get my free audit